When should you give advice?


Dear readers,

Sometimes the well of words runs dry and I struggle to find anything worthwhile to say to you. This was one of those weeks! Rather than turn to AI to generate an email message, I turned to the archives. Here’s an email I sent in September of 2020 that is just as relevant today. If you’ve been around since then, I’d love it if you’d hit reply and let me know!

~~~

I love getting emails from my readers with questions, because they are rarely the only person with that concern. A few days ago, I got this one:

How do you make suggestions to your sons/daughter-in-laws about your grandkids? It's all good--but sometimes I'm not thrilled with their parenting methods. Since I only have daughter-in-laws, I try to keep my mouth shut for fear of offending them in some way. It's a tricky balance!

Yes, dear friend, you are far from alone with that problem. It is extremely hard to sit back and keep your mouth shut when you see someone making what seems like a poor parenting choice, especially when your precious grandchildren are at stake. But there is no Best Way to be a good parent.

When I was pregnant with my third child, I joined an online support group for mothers expecting babies at the same time I was. A couple hundred women from all over the world participated, and over the years we discussed every aspect of parenting (and every other subject under the sun!). I quickly discovered that, while I was generally confident in my approach to raising children, there were other approaches that seemed to work equally well. From the early days of breast vs. bottle and who slept where, to potty training methods and effective discipline, to the eventual struggles with teenage rebellion, there were lots of women I respected who made decisions about their kids that just seemed wrong. Yet, it wasn’t my place to say so, because it wasn’t my family. All our children survived, even thrived, despite the many different ways they were raised.

Of course, as a grandparent it IS your family. So does that mean you should speak up if you don’t think your children are parenting the way they should? The answer is inevitably no, because what is really at stake is your relationship with your grown children. What sounds like an innocent suggestion to you will sound to them like a critical effort to control them. Creating tension in your relationship with your grown children will only make it harder to have a close relationship with your grandchildren. You may be right, there may be a better way. But there are lots of ways to raise children, and what looks to you like the wrong way to parent is really just a different way.

So, unless your grandchild is in danger of irreversible physical or emotional injury, take Jane Isay’s advice and “heed the eleventh commandment: Thou shalt not give your grown children advice.” Instead, support them with your time and unwavering sympathy and kindness. Being a parent is hard enough without having someone second guessing your decisions.

Warm regards,
DeeDee

P.S. I’ve recommended Jane Isay’s book on grandparenting, Unconditional Love: A Guide to Navigating the Joys and Challenges of Being a Grandparent Today, in the past. If you are having a difficult time with the relationship with one of your adult children, I also recommend her book Walking on Eggshells: Navigating the Delicate Relationship Between Adult Children and Parents. (These are affiliate links. If you make a purchase using these links, I may earn a small commission.)

We want to help you be a Most Valuable Grandparent! Visit our shop to see all our resources.

DeeDee Moore | Founder, More Than Grand LLC | morethangrand.com

Calling all new grandparents! (and parents, too!)

We cover topics that matter to grandparents - and parents - such as concrete ways to help new parents, understanding new trends in child care, and meaningful ways to connect the generations. The resources and products we offer foster open communication, encourage healthy boundaries, and equip new grandparents with the tools they need to become a supportive partner to their grandchild's parents. Sign up for our newsletter to find out why grandparenting isn't about spoiling the grandkids anymore. Parents welcome!

Read more from Calling all new grandparents! (and parents, too!)
Happy child shows off colorful, messy hands.

Hello, Reader! One day when I was visiting my son and his family recently, my grandson had a dentist appointment right after lunch. While my daughter-in-law took him, I stayed home with my granddaughters. The girls were happily playing outside when my daughter-in-law left, but she asked me to call them in after about twenty minutes so they could have some quiet time apart from one another. “They don’t know they need it, but if they don’t get a break in the middle of the day, they’ll start...

Fireworks exploding in the dark night sky.

Hello, Reader! It’s quiet right now at my house. Actually, it’s quiet in my house every morning. I almost always wake up before Pops, and I start the day with just the birds and an occasional passing car. It’s such a peaceful part of the day: drinking my tea, watching the swallows darting over the lake, playing all the NY Times word games. It’s a different kind of quiet this morning: the quiet of anticipation. Our daughters started arriving on Sunday, so there are sleeping people upstairs....

Mother lovingly breastfeeds her baby.

Dear Reader, Get ready for a sobering statistic: Up to 20% of new moms struggle with postpartum depression or anxiety. This means one in five mothers of our grandchildren is grappling with mental health issues. At the same time as adjusting to the demands of becoming a parent! Becoming a parent is a hard enough transition as it is, without the added stress of a postpartum mood or anxiety disorder. Grandparents are perfectly positioned to help: We have the experience and perspective to spot...